Works but not worth it
The plain 200-day rule: smaller drops, not enough to pass
The idea
After the 32-variant search was ruled out, we tried the simplest thing nobody had tuned: give each of 23 ETFs an equal slot, hold the slot while the fund's close is above its 200-day average, check monthly, otherwise sit in T-bills.
What we did
The rule, both windows (2017–2021 and 2022–2023), and the pass criteria were committed before the run, and it was run once. Pass rule per window: worst drop at most 60% of an equal-weight basket of the same 23 ETFs, and Sharpe not more than 0.10 below that basket. Both windows had to pass.
What happened
| Sharpe | Yearly return | Worst drop | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017–2021 | |||
| 200-day rule | 0.97 | 8.97% | 13.4% |
| Equal-weight basket | 0.85 | 9.04% | 17.7% |
| SPY buy and hold | 0.92 | 18.28% | 33.7% |
| 2022–2023 | |||
| 200-day rule | −0.05 | 3.28% | 6.1% |
| Equal-weight basket | −0.07 | 2.74% | 12.4% |
| SPY buy and hold | 0.12 | 4.26% | 22.1% |
- 2017–2021: fail. Worst drop was 0.76 of the basket's; the bar was 0.60.
- 2022–2023: pass. Worst drop was 0.49 of the basket's. The year stocks and bonds fell together.
The official runs
These are the official default-cost results for the pre-registered 200-day overlay and its equal-weight control, both run once per window. Sharpe and yearly return credit idle cash at the 3-month T-bill rate, like the figures already on this page. Worst drop is from the simulated book as traded. The SPY rows are reference points, not trials; the same-days row is frictionless.
| 2017–2021 | Sharpe | Yearly return | Worst drop | Time invested |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 200-day rule Pre-registered | 0.97 | 8.97% | 13.4% | 65% |
| Equal-weight basket of the same 23 funds Control | 0.85 | 9.04% | 17.7% | 68% |
| SPY, same invested days Reference | 0.97 | 11.18% | 20.3% | 65% |
| SPY, fully invested Reference | 0.92 | 18.28% | 33.7% | 100% |
| 2022–2023 | Sharpe | Yearly return | Worst drop | Time invested |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 200-day rule Pre-registered | −0.05 | 3.28% | 6.1% | 39% |
| Equal-weight basket of the same 23 funds Control | −0.07 | 2.74% | 12.4% | 60% |
| SPY, same invested days Reference | 0.00 | 3.52% | 6.9% | 39% |
| SPY, fully invested Reference | 0.12 | 4.26% | 22.1% | 100% |
The rule's worst drop was 0.76 of the basket's in 2017–2021 (bar 0.60: fail) and 0.49 in 2022–2023 (pass). Each of the two was also run at zero costs and at double the usual spread, which makes up the 6 overlay and 6 control trials. Costs hardly move either:
| Sharpe (cash at T-bill rate) | Zero costs | Default costs | Double spread |
|---|---|---|---|
| 200-day rule, 2017–2021 | 0.97 | 0.97 | 0.96 |
| Equal-weight basket, 2017–2021 | 0.85 | 0.85 | 0.85 |
| 200-day rule, 2022–2023 | −0.05 | −0.05 | −0.06 |
| Equal-weight basket, 2022–2023 | −0.06 | −0.07 | −0.07 |
Why it isn't worth it
It does cut the damage, especially in 2022-style markets. The registered miss is the 2017–2021 drop target: the worst drop was 0.76 of the equal-weight basket's, and our bar was 0.60. We did not adjust the pass rule after seeing this.
The rule did not give up a large return relative to the same 23 funds. In 2017–2021 it earned 8.97% a year against the basket's 9.04% (−0.07 percentage points), and in 2022–2023 it earned 3.28% against the basket's 2.74% (+0.54). Both the rule and the unfiltered basket lagged SPY in 2017–2021 (18.28% a year; about 18.3% in the prose on this site). That gap is the cost of holding this basket, not something the 200-day rule itself caused. In 2022–2023 its Sharpe was still below SPY's (−0.05 against 0.12).
It is the base for the drawdown brake, which passed its own test against this rule but did not beat holding SPY on the same days.
Receipts: the rules were written down and committed before any run. 6 overlay and 6 control trials.